The New Normal Is: Abnormal – It Won’t Last

by Darwin on July 1, 2009

Much has been made of the new catchphrase “The New Normal” which is becoming the phrase du jour for news outlets and talk shows.  While the phrase was initially coined by PIMCO’s Mohamed El-Erian (or at least caught on after his statements on the economy), the press has taken it to a whole new level and in a different direction. Now, ABC News has an entire section of their website and a segment on The New Normal and 20/20 just did a segment on it last week.  The premise of The New Normal in this context has generally been that America is now learning to be more frugal.  We learned our lesson!  They delve into these stories where the advertising executive that was making $250K per year and didn’t save a dime for retirement is now serving up coffee at a Starbucks doing what he has to do to make ends meet.


The New Normal as Initially Described by El-Erian

For the next 3–5 years, we expect a world of muted growth, in the context of a continuing shift away from the G-3 and toward the systemically important emerging economies, led by China. It is a world where the public sector overstays as a provider of goods that belong in the private sector. (As one of our speakers put it, we have transitioned from a world where the private sector provided public goods to one where the public sector provides private goods.) It is also a world in which central banks and treasuries will find it difficult to undo smoothly some of the recent emergency steps. This is particularly consequential in countries, such as the U.K. and U.S., where many short-term policy imperatives materially conflict with medium-term ones.”

He goes on to posit that markets will revert to historical means, the financial system will become delevered and government will play a bigger role in peoples’ lives.  I don’t think what’s being sold by the mainstream media for the “new normal in America” is what Mr. El-Erian had in mind.

The New Normal in the Press

As the media is portraying it now (and I wonder how much of the current fear, economic slump, spending reductions and subsequent layoffs can be attributed to the constant barrage of media hype over the past year), America has seen the light.  We’re now a country of frugal savers, cost cutters, no longer interested in keeping up with the Joneses.  Personally, I feel this view is completely naive and within 2 years, we will revert back to our mean, which is a culture of excess, jealous self-loathing, low self-esteem that drives excessive spending (the “bling” and “cribs” phenomena), and other “excuses” to feed our insatiable appetite for material things.  With a low value assessed to our inner worth, Americans tend to try to buy the perception of worth in the eyes of others. I recall for the longest time, my wife would see an expensive car drive by or someone we’d meet would pull up in the latest $50,000 car and she’d be awed saying, “Wow, they’ve got some money” or something to that effect.

I tried to explain time and time again that there is virtually no correlation between the actual net worth of an individual and their vehicle.

After a few experiences where it became evident that people we knew were either leasing their cars, in serious debt or just had different priorities than us (where we chose to put funds toward a house, retirement, having kids and other expenses, some people chose to focus on a car – to each his own), she eventually came to the realization that you can’t judge a person by their car.  Most people don’t figure this out until it’s too late, after they’ve already played the game.

If you believe what the press is touting, America has turned the corner. The only temporary barrier at the moment is restricted credit availability, a rise in unemployment and a temporary press blitz scaring people on the fence into being savers for now.

If you consider prior events like 9/11, Obama’s win, etc., each time, it was practically accepted that we were in a new America – things were going to be different from here on out – and within months, things always revert back to the old normal, not a new normal.  What’s different about this time around?

How many times have you heard the story about the couple close to retirement that had to totally rethink their retirement plans and keep working because they lost so much in their portfolio during the recent market crash?  Well, didn’t this just happen a few years ago when the .com bubble burst?  We don’t learn.

With unemployment on a path to hit 10%, the reality is, there’s only about 5% of the working population who experienced a layoff and may change some habits temporarily. With a standing 5% of the eligible workforce always collecting benefits in the best of economies, the remainder is 1 out of 20 people.  What about the other 19 out of 20 that have seen no layoff, no or little change in income, etc?  What about the current population of college students that grew up watching their parents free-wheeling spending habits, heavy reliance on credit, material consumption to extremes?  This population will soon be entering the workforce in a recovering economy ready to emulate their peers.  Only the newest line of clothing will do.  The happy hours and new BMW like their co-workers are the only way to fit in.

You tell me these kids are going to be out clipping coupons, cutting their bounce sheets in half and putting low flow shower heads in their $3000/month rented apartments in Manhattan?

What’s My Point?

The point is I don’t believe the hype.  And I don’t think you should either. Where there’s a will there’s a way.  While credit is tight now and it’s tough to get a cash-out refi, within a few years, the industry will have emerged with new “financial innovations” and other legal ways to give Americans what they want – unsecured credit – whenever they want it.  The best thing we can each do individually is to live within our means, live responsibly, have a reasonable emergency fund, continually rethink your career ambitions/training to be employable in the future economy, invest wisely for a rainy day and not live to excess.  However, a large enough portion of Americans will no doubt revert back to their normal, which is unfortunate.

I’d Love to Hear Your Thoughts.

Do you believe we’ll truly emerge from this with a New Normal?  Or we’ll see more of the same?

You're Not Following Darwin's RSS? Check out Why You Have to Subscribe to Darwin's Finance!

If you enjoyed this post, you can get free updates through RSS Feed or via Email whenever a new post is published. Rest assured that you can unsubscribe at any time via the automated system and your information will not be sold, archived or utilized for any other "nefarious" purposes.

{ 3 trackbacks }

Carnival of Personal Finance: New Zealand Edition! | Man Vs. Debt
July 13, 2009 at 4:30 am
The 45th Bankruptcy & Debt Carnival- Links Online…
July 13, 2009 at 7:41 am
» Festival of Frugality Goes For The Win! on the Festival of Frugality
July 14, 2009 at 1:49 pm


1 Mark Wolfinger July 2, 2009 at 3:53 pm


But it will last for a VERY short time.

Memories are short – per your example of the technology bubble.

Mark Wolfinger’s last blog post..Neutralizing Risk When Trading Options II

2 Stephanie PTY July 13, 2009 at 10:59 pm

I do agree with you somewhat. I believe that in a few years, we’ll start in experience some very high inflation. Who loses out in high inflation? People who have a lot of money in savings. America will lose its taste for saving when that happens.

But I have to disagree with you about the idea of the privilaged youth. I just graduated from college this year, and I see a different picture from where I am. A lot of us are scared. Far fewer people have jobs lined up that I would have hoped – I myself don’t even have one yet, even though I graduated in February instead of May (and not for lack of trying). A lot of us are just trying to get by, taking low-paying jobs or moving back home (to parents who may or may not charge rent). I hope my peers learn from this adversity, because it could go either way. This has not been a great year to graduate in!

Stephanie PTY’s last blog post..Moving: 8 Tips to Avoid Scams on Craigslist

3 Darwin July 13, 2009 at 11:22 pm

You’re right, I shouldn’t stereotype completely. I had graduated a decade ago and saw these behaviors everywhere amongst people my age and I feel like the country’s only moved even more in that direction during the 2000s so it would be worse by now, but perhaps given the economic realities and lack of job prospects that existed during prior graduating classes, some of the recent-grad behaviors will change for the current generation (one can only hope!). Good luck on your search!

4 Dren July 19, 2009 at 2:08 pm

Massive congratulations on your wife-persuasion skills! I am in awe.

Actual cases of persuasion against well-entrenched, media-supported beliefs seem rare.

Could you do a blog post on your approach and technique? Share!

5 backlaro December 16, 2010 at 8:04 am

“I just graduated from college this year, and I see a different picture from where I am. A lot of us are scared. Far fewer people have jobs lined up that I would have hoped – I myself don’t even have one yet, even though I graduated in February instead of May (and not for lack of trying). A lot of us are just trying to get by, taking low-paying jobs or moving back home (to parents who may or may not charge rent). I hope my peers learn from this adversity, because it could go either way.”
Are you sure that this is true?

Comments on this entry are closed.